Dir. Alexander Payne | 2004
Despite the fact that Paul Giamatti was seriously snubbed by the academy for his performance in this film, he pretty much made it. Church did a fine job as well, but without the contrast to Giamatti’s pathetic disposition, his wild rendering of a man on his last bachelor leg would have been more annoying than it was originally.
The problem with a road movie about a recent divorcee (and according to most popular film, “recent” constitutes as long as it takes to get over your ex-) is that they all ultimately come off the same; guy mopes, his friend takes him out, he screws it up initially because he’s still hung-up, and then finally finds the courage to go at it with sincerity because he’s found someone he sincerely likes.
Comedic moments notwithstanding, and there are quite a few of them, Giamatti has the uncanny facial expression of a man never comfortable with his own skin. He isn’t the most attractive of men, and hell, even Church has a oldness to him that makes his face look a lot more leathery than in his Wings days. The fact that both are relatively normal looking and live less than glamorous lives, well, it’s a far cry from Swingers.
Church acting like he’d fuck a zebra if it looked like it would give him its stripes was ugly but funny to watch. Watching Giamatti is just depressing. What’s more inviting about Sideways, rather than the drunk depressive or the out-of-control womanizer, is the dynamics of the relationship between Giamatti and Church, the more or less unconditional acceptance of the others flaws and respective shortcomings. And this isn’t just one or two things with each person, both characters have several, severe handicaps.
The way Alexander Payne works in this film is a lot like the others, they always start out with people of absolutely inane and poor character. Weak-willed and mopey, but eventually they break out of their shell to what may or may not be construed as “coming into their own”. In Election, we saw Matthew Broderick working as a tour guide in Washington, D.C., seemingly happier but more learned than when we first met him. In About Schmidt (which was the weakest of the three of Payne’s films), Nicholson coped and excelled past the death of his wife, but when all was ssaid and done, his wife was still dead, and Jack Nicholson was still Jack Nicholson (the same Nicholson that didn’t deserve an Oscar nomination for the same old shit).
Sideways works the same way, where the conclusion plays out of your own personal feelings about the situation. It’s not entirely an open ending, but you get the idea. The difference between these and the other films is still Giamatti. And yet no nomination.
The women in the film are for the most part, used. It’s not as bad as it seems though, because this film isn’t really about the women dealing with their divorces, deadbeat husbands or cheating boyfriends; it’s about one man’s struggle with insignificance. The best line of the entire film is “I’m so insignificant, I can’t even kill myself.” And with Church, the road, some wine and just a little spark, he builds on what little he has going for him.
It’s rare that you start with a decent script these days, and with that, Giamatti took this average coming-of-age-again road film and turned it into something that wouldn’t have gotten as much hype if someone else was cast. But if the Academy was fair, Scorsese would have gotten the Best Director award at least 4 nominations ago.